Imagine you’re the CEO of a multinational corporation. What

1

Multinational pharmaceutical companies veritably discover, extract, fabricate, and

distribute treatment from outdated faculty medicinal vegetation. Please read “The Case of

Hoodia,” a fictional tale of a right-lifestyles jam that entails more than one

stakeholders, including the San, the oldest continual human inhabitants of Africa,

a multinational pharmaceutical firm, the health concerns of overweight folks round

the realm, a immense pan-African authorities research organization, and a South

African non-governmental organization.

After ending the reading, solution questions 1 and 2.

———————————–

The Case of Hoodia

“So, what fabricate you fabricate?”

Angela Bingham turned to her seatmate and tried to muster a right smile. Though

she used to be gay alongside with her work, Angela disliked being asked the kind of internal most, invasive inquire by a

stranger. On the opposite hand, she used to be caught sitting next to this man for the rest of her 11-hour

flight to Cape Metropolis, so she made up our minds to begin up a diminutive bit.

“I work for a firm called Pharmedics. It’s a British pharmaceuticals discipline that

specializes in organising treatment from outdated faculty medicinal vegetation. The medicines we work on are

ancient to treat asthma, Parkinson’s disease, Alzheimer’s disease, AIDS…you title it. My latest

challenge is model of an extract from a plant called Hoodia Gordonii. It grows in the wild all

over southern Africa and has been ancient by the San, or the Bushmen of the Kalahari, for

hundreds of years. The San are essentially the most important human inhabitants of Africa. They take Hoodia to stave

off starvation and thirst on long attempting and gathering expeditions and all over events of drought. The

extract, P57, could presumably slay as much as be an anti-weight problems wonder drug.”

“Wow, that sounds attention-grabbing and just like the truth is factual work. Are you a scientist?”

“No, I’m an tale director. Truly, Pharmedics is a virtual firm—there are very

few of us who are employed straight by the firm itself. I work with outsourced field

2

researchers, lab scientists, clinicians, and manufacturers. I’m a middleman; I fabricate a

communications approach between the stakeholders and I coordinate feasibility studies for

research and manufacturing. Pharmedics works on preliminary isolation of extracts. We proceed the

commercialization as much as the mountainous boys.”

“The ‘mountainous boys’?”

“Yeah, Phizer, Unilever—mountainous multinational pharmaceutical companies. They’ve got the cash

and the energy to push treatment thru the Food and Drug Administration and such. But repeat me,

what fabricate you fabricate, um…I will’t mediate I already forgot your title…”

Angela’s seatmate smiled graciously. “Roger. Don’t apprehension about it—I’m an artist, a

sculptor, so I’m a diminutive bit flighty myself. I’m bringing a commissioned work to Cape Metropolis to be

placed in entrance of the headquarters of a mountainous shipbuilding firm. I work with steel. The pieces

of the sculpture are down in the bags compartment. I’m going to South Africa to effect all of them

together.”

“Properly, smartly,” beamed Angela, “that’s as soon as rapidly what I’m going to Cape Metropolis to fabricate, achieve

together pieces. But I’m no artist. This is more like a gross sales job, although I’m no longer somewhat clear what

I’m promoting or to whom.”

In short saved from having to reward additional by the advent of the dinner cart, Angela

leaned assist in her seat and closed her eyes. She recalled the conversation she’d had the outdated

week alongside with her firm’s president, David Campbell, when she used to be at the open dispatched on this

mission.

“Angela, I correct desire you to know that you’ve performed impossible work on the scientific trials

of P57. It has colossal industrial doable and Phizer is terribly focused on taking it to the following

3

stage. But Angela, nothing can occur the least bit unless we work things out with the San. I’ve got their

authorized legitimate, reporters from the Observer, a bunch of NGOs, and the governments of Namibia,

Botswana, and South Africa breathing down my neck…it’s impossible. I didn’t even know the

San existed anymore. I need you to fling over there and produce all people happy.”

Angela’s coronary heart pounded. She used to be ancient to bringing folks together to work as a group, however

this sounded grand more refined than what she in overall did. “David, I’m no longer clear I

perceive what you must derive me to fabricate. Why fabricate we derive an discipline with the San? They don’t derive

the enchancment license on the patent for Hoodia, we fabricate.”

Taking off his glasses, David Campbell stood and began pacing the room. “We bought

the enchancment rights for Hoodia from the preliminary patent holder, the South African-based mostly

Council for Scientific and Industrial Research (CSIR), one of essentially the most important research organizations

in Africa. Though it used to be a authorities-backed institution, it did no longer seek the advice of with the San,

the unique holders of the sure wager of Hoodia, ahead of applying for the patent. Even in the event that they’d

approached them, the San could presumably derive had diminutive have confidence for an apartheid-technology institution. They could no longer

derive even understood what used to be at stake for them. The San’s approach of lifestyles has been undermined by

model in southern Africa. The San are poverty-afflicted and they lack education and access

to data, so that they derive got diminutive energy to negotiate or profit from organising their indigenous

data…anyway, a South African NGO called BioWatch got wind of the CSIR agreement

with us and leaked it to the press.”

Angela used to be beginning to web on. “So fabricate the San mediate they are the factual homeowners of

Hoodia? Assemble they wish some produce of economic compensation for his or her data of Hoodia?”

“To repeat you the truth, the San gain the very idea that someone could presumably aloof pay them for his or her

data morally abhorrent. The San culture values data as a collective handy resource.

4

What’s more, the complete patent job makes diminutive sense to them. They don’t test up on how lifestyles—

even plant lifestyles—could presumably be ‘owned.’”

Sitting assist down at his desk, Campbell went on to reward how issues were made even

more refined by the truth that the San weren’t a single community, however a group of more than one

a ways-flung communities that lived and travelled throughout South Africa, Namibia, and Botswana.

An advocacy organization had been fashioned in 1996 to foyer for the pursuits of the San

communities, the Working Group of Indigenous Minorities in Southern Africa (WIMSA).

By their authorized legitimate, WIMSA had currently informed Pharmedics and the CSIR of their resolution

no longer to pursue the San’s ‘no patents on lifestyles’ policy in court, as it used to be too costly. In its effect, the

San wished to negotiate a advantages-sharing agreement, with Hoodia royalties being ancient to

alleviate poverty and care for endangered aspects of San culture. The distribution of such advantages

used to be, however, doubtlessly problematic. Although an agreement could presumably very smartly be reached between the

CSIR, Pharmedics, and WIMSA, how could presumably a arrangement be created to somewhat compensate more than one

nomadic San groups across three nations?

Angela used to be overwhelmed however clear. “David, I will’t mediate what a puzzle you’ve

placed in entrance of me. I’ll fling to Cape Metropolis. I will’t promise I’ll produce all people happy, however I’ll strive

to wait on all people glimpse the complete numerous transferring substances and how they’ll finest match together.”

“Ma’am, would you want eggs or French toast?”

Angela’s consideration snapped assist into the present.

“Oh, uh, thank you. French toast, please.” She looked a ways from the steward and over

in the direction of Roger. His dinner tray had been replaced with one featuring eggs and toast, and the solar

used to be vibrant brightly thru the window.

5

“Properly factual morning, sleepyhead, correct in time for breakfast! You passed out with out even

taking a chunk of dinner. I didn’t desire to wake you—I hope that’s o.ok. We’ve handiest got about a more

hours ahead of touchdown.”

“Oh sure, pointless to say. Roger, can I ask you something? You acknowledged you’re going to Cape

Metropolis to effect the pieces of your steel sculpture together. How exactly are you going to fabricate that?”

“Properly, you derive chose your approach looking out on the categories of metals you are working with.

If the metals are the identical, it is advisable to presumably presumably weld them together. It takes numerous heat and it’s dreadful,

however if you are cautious the joining will last a long time. If the metals are numerous, it’s very

worthy to power them alongside with welding. You as soon as rapidly prefer to yelp some produce of fastener

like bolts or rivets. You with regards to a resolution the technique to envision the substances.”

“Thanks, Roger. I’m beginning to guage I could presumably aloof conceive of my job in Cape Metropolis

more in relation to sculpting than promoting. You’ve helped me loads.”

Angela leaned assist in her seat. She used to be grateful Roger had asked her what she did for a

residing; moreover, she used to be happy she’d chosen to dispute heart’s contents to him. She smiled to herself, and this

time it used to be valid.

________________

In accordance with Dr. Martha Honey, co-founder and co-director of the Heart on Ecotourism and Sustainable Improvement, ecotourism is fling back and forth to fragile, pristine, and in overall obtain areas that strives to be low impact and is as soon as rapidly puny-scale. It helps educate the traveler, affords funds for conservation, straight advantages the economic model and political empowerment of local communities, and fosters appreciate for numerous cultures and for human rights.

Please read “A Monumental Jam,” a fictional tale of a fling back and forth reporter's journey conducting research for a fling back and forth journal article about ecotourism in Cambodia. After ending the reading, solution questions 1 and 2.

A Monumental Jam

It is a ways 4:30 a.m. and as promised, my book and driver, Kim San, is calling ahead to me at the hotel entrance. We had met the outdated day to work out a sightseeing time table for the week, and he insisted that essentially the most important part I fabricate on my tour of the Angkor Archaeological Park used to be test up on the morning time over Angkor Wat, essentially the most important non secular monument on this planet.

I climb aboard Kim San's bike, and we're off. My coronary heart races as we weave in and out of the streets of Siem Reap, the boomtown launching point for hundreds and hundreds of yearly guests to Angkor. In the darkness, the bike headlights point to black kinds of girls and men bustling to region up retail outlets and eating areas that will abet the waking hordes of vacationers.

It's a seven-kilometer pressure to essentially the most important designate gross sales field to Angkor Wat. Kim San stops in entrance of a immense, approved complex, constructed to fling immense crowds fleet thru the concession.

Hiking off the bike, I discover round. “Kim San, you acknowledged this effect could presumably be packed, however there's rarely someone here.”

Kim San smiles. “Many folks wait to near assist unless correct ahead of the solar rises. I derive guided journalists ahead of. I know you must prefer to derive the finest peep, and that is the reason I brought you here early. You must test up on, mediate me. Here, you must take a flashlight or it is advisable to fling back and forth and tumble. You need to buy your designate at the gross sales field,” says Kim San. “I will bring water. Apply me.”

Looming in the distance, I sense the presence of Angkor Wat, even though it lies nearly about 2 kilometers away. Designated in 1993 as a United Countries Academic, Scientific, and Cultural Group (UNESCO) World Heritage Put apart, Cambodia's Angkor Wat temple used to be also a finalist in the Unusual Seven Wonders of the World opponents in 2007. It is a ways the finest-preserved structure in the complex of over 1000 temples recognized collectively as Angkor, the Sanskrit word for city. Angkor flourished between the ninth and 15th centuries A.D. as the seat of the Khmer empire, which dominated over substances of present-day Laos, Thailand, Vietnam, Myanmar, and Malaysia. It used to be essentially the most important preindustrial metropolis on this planet, with a inhabitants of nearly about a million and an city footprint roughly the scale of approved Los Angeles. Since its founding in the 12th century, the temple complex of Angkor Wat has remained an challenging non secular middle, first dedicated to the Hindu god Vishnu, then re-dedicated to Theravada Buddhist yelp in the 14th or 15th century. It is a source of immense nationwide satisfaction and has been depicted on each model of the Cambodian flag since 1863.

Kim San leads me to a designate window. At this hour, there are more workers and guards lingering about than vacationers. I pay my $60 US price for per week's entrance to the park and am taken to a facet room to derive my picture taken for the fling. While waiting I fabricate some speedy psychological calculations. In my background research, I read that there had been nearly about three million yearly guests to Angkor. That's $180 million US—a immense earnings source for a nation with a Inappropriate Domestic Fabricated from handiest about $10 billion US.

“Tickets are costly, aren't they?” I voice to Kim San as we produce our approach assist to his bike for the remaining 2-kilometer crawl. “Angkor Wat brings in a immense quantity of money to Cambodia.”

“I wager so,” he responds. “Cambodians obtain to enter for free, which is factual, however no person the truth is is aware of exactly the effect the cash goes that is easy from foreigners. In 1999 the authorities gave a 10-year lease to a internal most firm called Sokimex to address the complete designate gross sales in Angkor. A particular person named Sok Kong owns Sokimex, and he is a internal most friend and creditor to Top Minister Hun Sen and his family. Sokimex is purported to present $10 million US per year to Aspara, the authorities company that oversees and manages the archaeological park. Of us judge that most of that cash the truth is ends in the hands of corrupt authorities officials, because rarely any of it is a ways spent to preserve the sites in the park.”

“Is Angkor falling into disrepair?”

“Yes,” says Kim San, “three million pairs of hands and feet brushing up towards the sandstone bricks of the temples does numerous wreck, no longer to mention looting and vandalism, the complete extinguish produced, and the water ancient. Overuse of water destroyed the unique city of Angkor, and now overuse is undermining the temples' sand basis—the bottom is literally sinking.”

.

As we bustle in the direction of Angkor Wat, I perceive I derive an discipline. The journal dispatched me on this assignment to quilt Angkor as an ecotourism online page online—to convey how tourism has helped revive Cambodia's unwell economy and withhold the local culture and ambiance. This data about designate gross sales, temple destruction, and pollution appears to be like to be to fling towards the ecotourism focus of my tale.

7 '

Kim San stops alongside the long moat we'll prefer to fallacious to enter essentially the most important temple complex. As we stroll, Kim San continues his commentary. “Most Cambodians are happy with the tourism, Joseph. Even the anchovy paste sellers in Siem Reap are making cash. We’re safe—the Khmer Rouge is gone—so most Cambodians feel that letting Sok Kong, Hun Sen, and their cronies preserve the cash is a puny worth to pay for the advance of our safety, economic standing, and cultural recognition throughout the realm.”

From my research, I know that Khmer Rouge is the title given to Cambodia's ruling celebration between 1975 and 1979. When the Khmer Rouge came to energy in 1975, they declared that year to be Year Zero. All Cambodian ancient past and culture ahead of Year Zero used to be to be destroyed and replaced by the original innovative culture, beginning from scratch. Foreigners weren't allowed in the nation; the truth is, Cambodia used to be cleave assist off from the rest of the realm unless 1992, when the United Countries started its peacekeeping mission.

When we attain the stay of the tower, Kim San instructs me to search out a effect to sit down down. There's nothing to fabricate now however watch for the solar to upward thrust and point to the peep. In the stillness, I slowly turn into responsive to the sound of water buffalo transferring thru the waters of the moat and muffled chants of nearby monks. Over 100,000 folks stay within the boundaries of the

archaeological park, making Angkor a residing, breathing mannequin of Cambodia's cultural heritage.

At last morning time breaks, the solar bathes the temple towers in a golden gentle, and hundreds of intricate sculptures, carvings, and stone reliefs emerge from the shadows. I'm startled out of my reverie by a group of vacationers huffing and puffing up the steps at the aid of us and fussing to their book that they're gradual and they've omitted the morning time.

“I'm sorry, Madame. I'm shy the solar waits for no person, no longer even any individual who forgot her camera in the room.”

I laugh to myself at the artful respond. I'd been impressed to learn thru my background research that first charge guides like Kim San are licensed by the National Tourism Agency of Cambodia. All of them focus on distinctive English, preserve university levels, and are steeped in the culture and ancient past of the field. All this work earns them a day by day charge of between $10 and $20 US per day—a king's ransom in contrast with the approved Siem Reap salary of roughly $40 US per month. Even off-responsibility policemen, paid roughly $30 US per month, hang round around the temples, keen to book folks who with regards to a resolution towards hiring any individual in town.

The arrivals are increasing with the gentle. Busses are lining up on the opposite facet of the moat and the keepsake sellers are beginning their actual gross sales pitch.

“You were correct, Kim San, it's getting crowded round here. We could presumably discover?”

A bunch of monks stroll past, chanting and retaining vegetation, incense, and candles. The cameras click on away. Kim San explains, “They are celebrating Magha Puja, a day of veneration for Buddha and his teachings. The ceremony historically takes effect at evening. Nevertheless, now the monks also invent the outdated faculty ritual all over the day so that it is advisable to per chance receive cash from vacationers. This cash is ancient to fund a school the effect the monks fling on outdated faculty talents in arts and crafts to the locals so they in turn can promote these products to vacationers. When the monks derive completed performing their ceremony they’ll web pointers to derive their pictures focused on the vacationers.

I turn and watch three diminutive ladies, bracelets and bamboo flutes in hand, standing in the middle of a group of shouting vacationers.

“Canada! What's the capitol of Canada?”

“Ottawa!” responds one girl eagerly. “Ottawa in Ontario. Canada derive 10 provinces. Ontario, Quebec, Nova Scotia, Unusual Brunswick, Manitoba, British Columbia…” The kid goes on to rattle off the rest of the provinces, plus their capitals and relative populations.

The crowd loves it. Video cameras whirr away, recording the scene. “These

formative years are going to be on YouTube next week, aren't they?” I quip.

Kim San smiles. “They already are. They are presumably earning cash to pay their lecturers. The Khmer Rouge is gone, however we aloof derive a mountainous enemy in Cambodia: corruption. It is a ways everywhere. Academics charge formative years to enter the college room, and even white-haired outdated females need to pay off the military and/or police for the relate to beg in the temples. We pay below the table for the whole lot—birth certificates, fling back and forth visas, very most attention-grabbing rulings from judges, the whole lot. Every person wants the cash and all people can pay.”

A diminutive bit girl is tugging at my shirttail. “Handsome mister, the effect you from?”

“The United States,” I answer.

“The United States, very factual nation. Capitol Washington, D.C. You buy flutes to your formative years? Two flutes 2000 riels.”

“I'll buy your flutes if you solution some questions for me,” I cleave worth. “Bellow me, fabricate you fling to faculty?”

“No. My brothers fling to college. I produce cash so that they fling to college.”

“Why fabricate your brothers fling to college? What fabricate they want to fabricate when they develop up?”

“My brothers desire to derive a hotel. Compose numerous cash. They don't desire to work on farm. Too annoying work. No cash. Now you buy flutes?”

–

“Yes, now I'll buy your flutes.” Digging deep in my pockets for the 2000 riels, I gaze at Kim San, who, alongside with his university level, observes these interactions with tranquil amusement. I discover assist at the clear face of this diminutive salesgirl, who, at 8 or 9-years-outdated, presumably is aware of more geography than I fabricate. I hand her the 2000 riels and turn round to discover at Angkor Wat. With the solar rising at the aid of it, it glows like a beacon of hope and casts a extensive shadow under. At that moment, I know what the title of my article can be—Angkor Wat: A Monumental Jam.